Allopathic toothache remedies
On OTC chemical painkillers
This site generally recommends only natural and holistic ways of treating toothaches, including those involving excruciating pain, since these remedies can both be highly (even instantaneously) effective, are basically free of side effects (and typically less expensive than OTC or prescription drugs). A prime example is the use of salt water. But in certain situations, a chemical narcotic "club" (be it aspirin, acetaminophen / paracetamol [Tylenol], Ibuprofen, Vicodin, ...) can do wonders, but in my experience only when directly applied to the painful spot, by finally allowing sleep and rest, and hence the beginning of healing.
So while personally I would shun all of the following due to all the chemicals added to the formula and/or pills and go for salt water and/or other natural toothache and dental remedies instead whenever possible, obviously and by all means, I'd use and recommend using those chemical helpers in an emergency (where in my experience they can be a true blessing when topically applied!).
One major caveat would concern children whom I'd avoid exposing to potentially/likely toxic chemicals to the extent possible. Taking the safety warnings accompanying Orajel Maximum Strength Anesthetic Pain Relief Gel as an example (see below), these chemicals are not to be trifled with and possibly come with serious so-called "side effects" (in reality, these are simply effects, and sometimes grave ones, at least with continued ingestion). One of the most serious ones I have seen refers to ziconotide (aka Prialt or SNX-111) which according to a study authored by the Ruhr University in Bochum (Germany) has led to increased incidence of suicide. Also, aspirin, paracetamol (tylenol etc.), ibuprofen (motrin, advil etc.) and perhaps others apparently inhibit proper mineral absorption, with minerals of course being a pivotal nutrient for teeth as well as the rest of the body.1
As with natural pain relievers, chemical/allopathic analgesics or anti-toothache formulae are often just temporary remedies and will require your getting the tooth "fixed" by a dentist (which is also a temporary measure which can and in my and some others' view does damage the ailing tooth even more)2 or alternatively (and bravely) attempting to take its stabilisation and/or (in the best of cases) recovery in your own hands.
Here a list of chemical/allopathic toothache remedies including important warnings - generally be aware that (at least with long-term use) analgesics can cause gastro-intestinal bleeding (creating "holes" in the stomach and/or intestines) and liver / kidney damage since the body must detoxify / excrete them via these organs.
Allopathical analgesics and over-the-counter (OTC) medications are pain relievers such as aspirin, acetaminophen [Tylenol], Ibuprofen3 [Motrin, Advil, Nuprin] and hydrocodone [Vicodin], the most common perhaps being Aspirin and Paracetamol and its twin Acetaminophen4.
As mentioned, the only way I found them effective (though I have only tried one or two of them at two occasions) was by directly lodging them against the painful tooth. In fact in the few cases I know of where salt and salt water or other natural remedies (such as garlic or urine rinses) didn't bring relief, application of an analgesic (half topically, the other half by ingestion just to be on the safe side [ingesting alone proved rather fruitless in my experience]) may prove indispensable and stop the pain within minutes, thus allowing restful sleep and subsequent "peace of tooth", the forming of a "healing" abscess etc.
Incidentally, a variation of the direct application technique consists in the following: put several aspirin or other analgesics in a bowl and crush them. Add warm water (and optionally some salt). Soak a cotton ball in the solution and place it on or next to the painful tooth. Reheat the solution and reapply as needed.
Acetaminophen / Paracetamol (Tylenol, Panadol etc.4) caveats
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a warning that drugs containing acetaminophen can trigger three serious skin reactions, two of which (Stevens-Johnson Syndrome [SJS] and Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis [TENS] potentially fatal. These skin reactions can occur even in those who have taken Acetaminophen-containing products with impunity beforehand.
Further significant health risks linked to acetaminophen drugs (a least with chronic use) include blood cancer, brain damage, blood pressure increase, hearing loss, reduced lung function, eosinophilic pneumonia, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), acute renal failure, acute tubular necrosis, increased risk of renal cell carcinoma, and liver failure (drugs containing acetaminophen [which is toxic to the liver] are the number one cause of liver failure in the USA). www.drugs.com notes that "[i]n a recent retrospective study of 306 patients admitted for acetaminophen overdose, 6.9% had severe liver injury but all recovered. None of the 306 patients died."
Among the most serious findings can be included those of the 2014 study published in Inflammation & Allergy-Drug Targets: "The Alzheimer pandemic: is paracetamol to blame?" which concluded that Alzheimer's disease is "primarily a man-made condition with paracetamol as its principal risk factor".5
I have seen various warnings concerning the advice to lodge an aspirin directly against the aching gum or tooth (or biting down on it) to dull the pain for a while. While this should provide temporary toothache relief, it can also cause a so-called aspirin burn (inflammation of gum and cheek tissues).
A more serious warning concerns the connection of aspirin to developing Reye's Syndrome, a potentially fatal (but rare) disease afflicting children up to the ages of 19 and which can also cause severe abdominal bleeding in adults. Reye's syndrome most commonly occurs in children between four and nine years of age, damages liver and brain and leads to death in 40% of cases.
Last but not least, the Association of German nephrologists has called for a ban of aspirin since a large percentage of kidney damage cases is due to OTC aspirin (quoted from Die Heilkunst von Morgen).
Note: Regarding over-the-counter tooth pain relievers, a person commented that the "best toothache medication is one that contains a narcotic analgesic such as codeine. The best toothache antibiotic is usually Amoxicilin or Keflex, especially when a patient has a dental abcess toothache".
While "officially" used as a radical germ-fighter, Chlorhexidine has shown absolutely amazing effects with various types of toothache (including extreme ones) as well. For details see Chlorhexidine: a powerful conventional germ fighter and mouthwash for occasional and emergency use.
Both reported as an effective toothache remedy (killing germs & offending bacteria that swarm in a "rotten" infected tooth) and as a preventive routine which helped forestall future toothaches and infections.
Warm salt water followed by rinsing with Listerine Antiseptic Mouthwash is also reported extremely effective, taking the pain away in minutes. As with salt water rinses, in cases of more intractable pain one could combine it for instance with the subsequent local application of half a painkiller tablet such as Aspirin directly applied to the offending tooth and/or at its base between the gums and cheek. Due to the gradual dissolving of the pill, it will numb the pain for quite a while.
Note: Johnson & Johnson, the company that makes Listerine, tests on animals, an important reason to not buy their products. Tips how to become a caring consumer.
Colgate Peroxyl mouthrinse
for mouth lesions, contains mostly peroxide.
Dr. Tichenor's antiseptic peppermint mouthwash concentrated formula
Available at drug stores/Walgreens. Use concentrated (no water added) directly on aching tooth, apply with dropper if available, let stand as long as possible (It will burn), spit, don't rinse, repeat as needed. Someone reported that it numbs the pain more effectively than tooth gels.
Also used for insect bites, sore throats and other purposes.
Gargle/rinse (a user promised quick pain relief), repeat as needed.
Orajel® Maximum Strength Anesthetic Pain Relief Gel
Main active ingredient: benzocaine. Also contains allantoin, benzalkonium chloride, clove oil, edetate disodium, peppermint oil, polyethylene glycol, propyl gallate, propylene glycol, purified water, sodium saccharin, sorbic acid, zinc chloride. Someone reported saying that it numbed the pain straight away and lasted "longer than most medicines". (A similar medication with the active ingredient benzocaine 20% is called Anbesol).
Orajel® comes with the following warnings:
"Allergy alert: Do not use this product if you have a history of allergy to local anesthetics such as procaine, butacaine, benzocaine or other 'caine' anesthetics.
Do not use
- more than directed
- for more than 7 days unless told to do so by a dentist or doctor.
Stop use and ask a doctor if
- swelling, rash or fever develops
- irritation, pain, or redness persists or worsens.
Keep out of reach of children. In case of overdose, get medical help or contact a Poison Control Center right away."
(Healing Teeth Naturally's comment: Mmh, this sounds like it must be good for you ...)
Likely available in drugstores/pharmacies and similar outlets under names such as "Dent's Toothache Gum" and perhaps others, I would suggest to first throughly rinse your mouth with warm salt water and if the pain persists, to cut a piece of gum to fit the painful tooth and apply. Since the gum creates a shield against food particles, air etc., it might be particularly useful for any exposed cavities or those hurting more when touched by food or air.
Even toothpaste pushed into the hole of an aching tooth has relieved pain "in seconds".
5 See www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3921468/ . Also refer to Alzheimer's & Dementia: On Suggested Causes & Cures.